You have already read the IGN and Gamespot scores. You have watched the trailers that show perfect sunsets and seamless combat. You have seen the Metacritic aggregate. But something feels off. That polished demo they showed at the conference? It looked incredible. The first five hours of the full game? They felt incredible. But you are a core gamer. You know that the first impression is a curated lie. The real game starts after the tutorial ends, after the review embargo lifts, and after the hype cycle moves on to the next big thing. We spent 30 hours living in this world. We ignored the main quest for hours just to poke at the edges. We found the parts that the major outlets missed. Here is the honest open world RPG review 2024 that you need before you hand over your sixty dollars.
This open world RPG delivers a stunning first 10 hours, but the middle act drags badly. The combat system is genuinely innovative, yet the enemy variety is a letdown. Performance on base consoles is worse than reviews suggest. The writing for side quests is surprisingly strong, but the main story loses focus. Wait for a sale unless you have a high-end PC or a PS5 Pro.
The First Ten Hours Are a Masterpiece
Nobody is lying about that. The opening sequence is tight. The world reveals itself slowly, like a good novel. You get a solid weapon, a compelling mystery, and a companion character who actually has personality. The major review sites were correct about the prologue. It is one of the best introductions in any RPG this generation.
But here is the thing they did not emphasize enough. That quality curve is a steep downhill slope. Around hour twelve, the handholding stops and the repetition begins. The main story path splits into three mandatory tasks that all feel identical. You are sent to three different zones to perform the same ritual. Talk to a faction leader. Clear a camp. Fight a mini-boss. Return for a cutscene.
The game does not respect your time here. I found myself fast traveling back to the hub, only to watch a loading screen that lasted forty seconds on my standard PS5. That might sound minor, but when you do it twenty times, it adds up.
The Combat Is Good, But the Enemy Roster Is Tiny
The combat system deserves praise. It combines real-time action with a pause-and-command system that feels fluid. You can swap between four party members on the fly. Each character has a unique resource meter that encourages aggressive play. Parrying has a generous window. Spellcasting feels impactful.
However, the game only has about fifteen enemy types. You will fight the same armored knight variant in zone one, zone four, and the final dungeon. They just change the color palette and increase the health bar. By hour twenty, I was bored of the combat encounters. The bosses are the exception. There are six major boss fights, and each one is a highlight. But the path between them is a slog of recycled grunts.
“The biggest issue is not the combat mechanics. It is the lack of respect for the player’s time. I beat the same bandit captain six times before I reached the second region. That is not difficulty. That is padding.” — Anonymous developer from a studio forum post
Performance Problems That Reviews Glossed Over
Most reviews mentioned “occasional frame rate dips.” That is a generous way to describe what happens in the game’s dense forest region. On a standard PS5, the frame rate drops to the low forties during rain effects. The Xbox Series S version has noticeable texture pop-in that can take up to five seconds. The PC version is better, but it suffers from shader compilation stutter every time you load a new area.
Here is a breakdown of what you can expect on different hardware:
| Platform | Resolution Target | Frame Rate Stability | Notable Issues |
|---|---|---|---|
| PS5 (Standard) | 1440p upscaled to 4K | 40-55 FPS in open areas | Severe drops in rain |
| PS5 Pro | Native 4K | 55-60 FPS | Minimal issues |
| Xbox Series X | 1440p upscaled to 4K | 45-55 FPS | Texture pop-in |
| Xbox Series S | 1080p | 30-40 FPS | Long load times |
| PC (RTX 4070) | 1440p | 60 FPS (with dips) | Shader stutter |
If you are on a base console, be ready for a rougher experience than the reviews let on.
Side Quests Are the Real Star
This is the part that surprised me. The main story is a generic chosen-one narrative with a forgettable villain. But the side quests? They are excellent. One quest chain involves a failed playwright who asks you to gather materials for a stage play. It ends with a genuinely emotional performance that uses the game’s engine in a creative way. Another quest has you tracking a serial killer through a series of crime scenes. It feels like a detective thriller dropped into a fantasy world.
The problem is that the game hides these quests behind a cluttered journal system. You have to read through pages of generic fetch quests to find the good ones. The game does not mark quality content differently from filler. I almost missed the playwright quest because it was buried between “Kill 10 wolves” and “Collect 5 herbs.”
If you are looking for a reason to buy this game, the side content is it. But you have to work to find it.
A Practical Guide to Getting the Most Out of This Game
If you decide to buy the game, do not play it the way the game wants you to. Follow this process instead:
- Ignore the main quest after the prologue. The story gets worse as you progress. Save the main quest for when you are bored of everything else.
- Focus on the journal entries that have unique character names. Generic entries like “Village Request” are filler. Named quests like “The Last Performance” or “Blood on the Cobblestones” are the good ones.
- Turn off the HUD compass. The game constantly points you to the next objective. This creates a feeling of obligation. Turn it off and explore naturally. You will find more interesting content.
- Fast travel sparingly. The world is designed for horseback travel. Fast traveling breaks the immersion and exposes the loading screens. Ride between objectives and listen to the party banter. It is some of the best writing in the game.
- Save before entering any new zone. There is a known bug on all platforms where entering a new region can trigger a soft lock if you are moving too fast. Save often.
What the Reviews Got Right
To be fair, the major outlets were not wrong. The game is beautiful. The art direction is cohesive. The music is memorable. The voice acting is solid. The character creator is one of the best in the genre. The game deserves an 8 out of 10 for the first half alone.
But a review score is a single number. It cannot tell you that the last ten hours feel like a different game. It cannot tell you that the final boss is a bullet sponge that takes twenty minutes of repetitive dodging. It cannot tell you that the ending is a cliffhanger that sets up paid DLC.
The Verdict for the Core Gamer
You are not a casual player. You have played the greats. You know what a 10 out of 10 feels like. This game is not that. It is a solid 7 that could have been a 9 with better pacing and more enemy variety. The honest open world RPG review 2024 that you need is this: buy it on sale, play the side quests, and stop playing when the main story starts to bore you. That is the way to enjoy this game.
For more insight into what is coming next, check out our list of top 10 upcoming RPGs that will redefine gaming in 2026. And if you want to make sure your hardware is ready, read our guide on how to optimize your gaming setup for maximum performance.
The Real Cost of Hype
We all want to believe that the next big release will be the one. The one that makes us feel like we did when we played our first RPG. This game comes close in moments. It has flashes of brilliance. But it is held back by the same problems that plague most modern open world games. It is too long. It is too safe. It is too afraid to trust the player.
Do not let the hype make the decision for you. Let the honest open world RPG review 2024 guide your purchase. Play it when you are ready to forgive its flaws. Play it for the side quests and the combat system. But do not expect a masterpiece. Expect a good game with great parts buried under a lot of filler. And that is okay. Not every game needs to be a masterpiece. Some games just need to be honest about what they are.